Benchmarking of the BITalino Biomedical Toolkit Against an Established Gold Standard
Fred, A. L. N.
; Moreira, C. F.
; Ferreira, H. F.
IET Healthcare Technology Letters Vol. 6, Nº 2, pp. 32 - 36, May, 2019.
ISSN (print): 2053-3713
ISSN (online): 2053-3713
Journal Impact Factor: (in 2014)
Digital Object Identifier: 10.1049/htl.2018.5037
The low-cost multimodal platform BITalino is being increasingly used for educational and research purposes. However, there is still a lack of well-structured work comparing data acquired by this toolkit against a reference device, using established experimental protocols. This work intends to fill said gap by benchmarking the performance of BITalino against the BioPac MP35 Student Lab Pro device. We followed a methodical experimental protocol to acquire data from the two devices simultaneously. Four physiological signals were acquired: Electrocardiography, Electromyography, Electrodermal Activity and Electroencephalography. Root mean square error and coefficient of determination were computed to analyze differences between BITalino and BioPac. Electrodermal activity signals were very similar for the two devices, even without applying any major signal processing techniques. For electrocardiography, a simple morphological comparison also revealed high similarity between devices, and this similarity increased after a common segmentation procedure was followed. Regarding electromyography and electroencephalography data, the approach consisted of comparing features extracted using common post-processing methods. The differences between BITalino and BioPac were again small. Overall, the results presented here show a close similarity between data acquired by the BITalino and by the reference device. This is an important validation step for all researchers working with this multimodal platform.